Examine the diagram below, which shows the hexagon, segments from its center to a vertex and the midpoint of a side, and the two circles.

Note that the segment from the center of the hexagon to the midpoint of a side is a radius of the inscribed circle, and the segment from the center to a vertex is a radius of the circumscribed circle. The two segments and half a side of the hexagon can be proved to form a 30-60-90 triangle.

The inscribed circle has circumference , so its radius - and the length of the longer leg of the right triangle - is

By the 30-60-90 Theorem, the length of the shorter leg is this length divided by , or ; the length of the hypotenuse, which is the radius of the circumscribed circle, is twice this, or . 

The area of the circumscribed circle can now be calculated:

Examine the diagram below, which shows the square, segments from its center to a vertex and the midpoint of  a side, and the two circles.

Note that the segment from the center of the square to the midpoint of a side is a radius of the inscribed circle, and the segment from the center to a vertex is a radius of the circumscribed circle. The two segments and half a side of the square form a 45-45-90 triangle, so by the 45-45-90 Theorem, the radius of the circumscribed circle is  times that of the inscribed circle.

The inscribed circle has circumference , so its radius is

The circumscribed circle has radius  times this, or , so its area is 

Examine the diagram below, which shows the square, segments from its center to a vertex and the midpoint of  a side, and the two circles.

Note that the segment from the center of the square to the midpoint of a side is a radius of the inscribed circle, and the segment from the center to a vertex is a radius of the circumscribed circle. The two radii and half a side of the square form a 45-45-90 Triangle, so by the 45-45-90 Theorem, the radius of the inscribed circle is equal to that of the circumscribed circle divided by .

The inscribed circle has circumference , so its radius is

Divide this by  to get the radius of the circumscribed circle:

The circumscribed circle has area 

Examine the diagram below, which shows the hexagon, segments from its center to a vertex and the midpoint of a side, and the two circles.

Note that the segment from the center of the hexagon to the midpoint of a side is a radius of the inscribed circle, and the segment from the center to a vertex is a radius of the circumscribed circle. The two segments and half a side of the hexagon can be proved to form a 30-60-90 triangle.

The circumscribed circle has circumference , so its radius - and the length of the hypotenuse of the right triangle - 

By the 30-60-90 Theorem, the length of the shorter leg is half this, or 5. The length of the longer leg, which is the radius of the inscribed circle, is  times this, or .

The area of the inscribed circle can now be calculated:

In order to compare the areas of the square and circle, we need to find an equivalence between the radius of the circle and the side-length of the square.

Let's take the first statement.  Tranlating it into math, we have:

Where r= the radius of the circle, and d= the length of the side of the square.  The important point is that we DO NOT HAVE TO SOLVE THIS.  All we need to recognize is that the equation makes a comparison between r and d.  That is what we are looking for.

Because the first statement makes a direct, numerical comparison between r and d, it is sufficient by itself to answer the question.

Let's look at the second statement.

Translating that into math, we get:

,

where d is the length of the square's side and r is the radius of the circle.

This also sets an equivalence (technically, an inequality) between d and r, and we could use that information to show whether the area of the circle is less than the area of the square.

Statement 2 is ALSO sufficient to answer the question.

So, the answer choice is D.  Both statements are sufficient on their own to answer the question.

Finding the area here is straightforward if we can use what we're given wisely. First, the area of a circle can be found using the following:

where  is area and  is our radius. Now, although we are not given our radius, we are given the diameter, just not by name.

Segment  goes from one point on the outside of the circle through the center to another point on the circle; that means its length is the circle's diameter.

If our diameter is , then our radius must be . Plug this into the area equation to find the area of our circle:

The area of circle is found by the following equation:

where  is our radius, which is .

So,

Using the formula for the area of a circle, we can plug in the given value for its radius and calculate our solution:

The area  of a circle is defined by , where  is the radius of the circle. We are provided with the diameter  of the circle, which is twice the length of .

If , then 

Then, solving for :

The equation of a circle centered at the origin of the coordinate plane is , where  is the radius of the circle.

The area  of the circle, in turn, is defined by the equation .

Since we are provided with the equation , we can deduce that  and that .