SAT Writing : Identifying Punctuation Errors: Commas

Study concepts, example questions & explanations for SAT Writing

varsity tutors app store varsity tutors android store varsity tutors ibooks store

Example Questions

Example Question #297 : Identifying Punctuation Errors

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

While it would be great if the Argentinian team won the championship I would be happy to see any South American team win. No error

Possible Answers:

it would be great if

While

championship

No error

to see any

Correct answer:

championship

Explanation:

“While it would be great if the Argentinian team won the championship” is a dependent clause, which means that it can be removed from the sentence and still leave a grammatically complete and logical sentence. Because commas are always used to separate a dependent clause from an independent clause, a comma must be placed between “championship” and “I would.”

Example Question #17 : Identifying Punctuation Errors: Commas For Dependent Clauses

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

No matter what I do, I can’t seem to convince the board of directors that achieving the designer’s vision will be impossible, when considering economies of scale. No error

Possible Answers:

the designer’s

No matter what I do,

impossible

can’t seem

No error

Correct answer:

impossible

Explanation:

“No matter what I do” is a dependent clause, so it must be separated from the rest of the sentence by a comma; however, “when considering economies of scale” is not a dependent clause in this case, so it shouldn’t be preceded by a comma. It is instead part of the preceding independent clause, and it can’t be removed from the sentence without losing some of the main idea.

Example Question #301 : Identifying Punctuation Errors

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

Being a weak speller I was not able to score well when it came time to write the inspirational essay; we were given no resources to check our spelling or grammar before we handed in the assignment. No error

Possible Answers:

to score well

Being a weak speller

before we handed in

No error

essay;

Correct answer:

Being a weak speller

Explanation:

“Being a weak speller” is a modifier that describes the narrator of the sentence, and it is a dependent clause. A comma is needed after “speller.” The semicolon is used correctly to separate two independent clauses without a conjunction here.

Example Question #1164 : Identifying Sentence Errors

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

The panel of scientists was fascinated by the rare species of tree frog, which was capable of producing toxins to incapacitate or even kill a full-grown horse, human, or cow. No error

Possible Answers:

human,

frog,

was

full-grown

No error

Correct answer:

No error

Explanation:

In this sentence, “which was capable of producing toxins to incapacitate or even kill a full-grown horse, human, or cow” is a dependent clause. In other words, it is non-essential information that can be removed and still leave a complete sentence; therefore, it is correctly separated from the independent clause with a comma. The items in the list are also correctly punctuated with commas.

Example Question #301 : Identifying Punctuation Errors

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

Being an unlikely candidate for governor the woman nevertheless charmed voters with her candor, fervency, and sardonic sense of humor. No error

Possible Answers:

Being an unlikely candidate for governor

nevertheless

candor,

No error

fervency,

Correct answer:

Being an unlikely candidate for governor

Explanation:

Here, “Being an unlikely candidate for governor” is a dependent clause. It relies on the independent clause (the rest of the sentence) for meaning, so it should be separated from that independent clause with a comma after “governor.” The list is punctuated correctly with commas here.

Example Question #301 : Identifying Punctuation Errors

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

Even with a combination of whiskey, opium, and assistants early amputations were grisly, excruciating procedures that often resulted in infection and death. No error

Possible Answers:

assistants

that often resulted in

grisly

No error

whiskey,

Correct answer:

assistants

Explanation:

Here, “Even with a combination of whiskey, opium, and assistants” is a dependent clause that depends upon the rest of the sentence (“early amputations were grisly, excruciating procedures that often resulted in infection and death”) for its meaning, so it should be separated from that independent clause with a comma after “assistants.”

Example Question #302 : Identifying Punctuation Errors

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

Ever since Joachim quit his last job he has been free to pursue his solo jazz career, and he has actually become quite skilled at improvisation. No error

Possible Answers:

pursue

quite skilled

No error

career,

Ever since Joachim quit his last job

Correct answer:

Ever since Joachim quit his last job

Explanation:

“Ever since Joachim quit his last job” is a dependent clause, so it should be separated from the rest of the sentence with a comma. There is also a comma after “career,” as we’re separating two independent clauses with a conjunction (“and”) and therefore we need a comma before that conjunction.

Example Question #303 : Identifying Punctuation Errors

Select the underlined word or words that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences may contain no error at all.

Above all you must remember to conjugate the verbs correctly on tomorrow’s test,” the French teacher said. No error

Possible Answers:

No error

test,”

tomorrow’s

Above all

the verbs

Correct answer:

Above all

Explanation:

Here, “Above all” is an introductory phrase and a dependent clause, so it must be followed by a comma. The direct speech is correctly punctuated in the original sentence.

Example Question #301 : Identifying Punctuation Errors

Select the underlined word or phrase that needs to be changed to make the sentence correct. Some sentences contain no error at all.

The student body cheered loudly and celebrated wildly, when summer vacation arrived once again. No error

Possible Answers:

student body

No error

wildly, when

arrived once

loudly and

Correct answer:

wildly, when

Explanation:

The comma used between "wildly" and "when" is extraneous and creates a grammatical error in this sentence. No comma is needed to separate the subordinate clause "when summer vacation arrived once again" from the independent clause "The student body cheered loudly and celebrated wildly." Note that if the order of these clauses were reversed and the sentence began with the subordinate clause, a comma would be needed after "again": "When summer vacation arrived once again, the student body cheered loudly and celebrated wildly"; however, since the subordinate clause follows the independent clause in the sentence as it is given, no comma is needed.

Learning Tools by Varsity Tutors