SAT Writing : Correcting Punctuation Errors: Commas

Study concepts, example questions & explanations for SAT Writing

varsity tutors app store varsity tutors android store varsity tutors ibooks store

Example Questions

Example Question #321 : Correcting Grammatical Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English.

Choosing a lighting fixture that works well with a room's design can be a difficult challenge, it is important that you look at the available options with a discerning eye.

Possible Answers:

Choosing a lighting fixture that works well with a room's design can be a difficult challenge, so it is important, that you look at the available options with a discerning eye.

Choosing a lighting fixture, that works well with a room's design, can be a difficult challenge, so it is important that you look at the available options with a discerning eye.

Choosing a lighting fixture that works well with a room's design can be a difficult challenge, but it is important that you look at the available options with a discerning eye.

Choosing a lighting fixture that works well with a room's design can be a difficult challenge, so it is important that you look at the available options with a discerning eye.

Choosing a lighting fixture that works well with a room's design can be a difficult challenge it is important that you look at the available options with a discerning eye.

Correct answer:

Choosing a lighting fixture that works well with a room's design can be a difficult challenge, so it is important that you look at the available options with a discerning eye.

Explanation:

This sentence contains a comma splice, an error in which two independent clauses (sentences that could each stand on their own) are improperly joined by a comma. When joining two independent clauses into a single sentence, one should use either a semicolon or a comma followed by a conjunction. Two of the possible answer choices employ a comma followed by a conjunction, but the answer choice that uses "but" is incorrect, because "but" should join independent clauses that contrast against one another, which the two independent clauses in question do not do. So, the correct answer is the answer choice that uses a comma and "so" to join the two independent clauses, because the relationship between the independent clauses is one of cause and effect, or reason and action taken due to the reason, not one in which the ideas contrast against each other.

 

Example Question #321 : Correcting Grammatical Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English.

She was quite wary of making a scene, she let the matter fade away with no comment.

Possible Answers:

She was quite wary of making a scene, but she let the matter fade away with no comment.

She was quite wary of making a scene, although she let the matter fade away with no comment.

She was quite wary of making a scene, so she let the matter fade away with no comment.

She was quite wary of making a scene, also she let the matter fade away with no comment.

She was quite wary of making a scene, she let the matter fade away with no comment.

Correct answer:

She was quite wary of making a scene, so she let the matter fade away with no comment.

Explanation:

The sentence is composed of two independent clauses—two complete sentences, joined to show their connection; however, the two are joined only by a comma, creating an error known as a "comma splice." Independent clauses should be joined by a semi-colon or by a comma followed by a conjunction (a word like "and" or "but"). To correct this sentence, you could either change out the comma for a semi-colon, or insert an appropriate conjunction immediately after the comma.

Let's consider the possible answer choices. The answer choice that makes no changes to the sentence can't be correct, since the sentence does contain an error. "Also" is an adverb, not a conjunction, so the answer choice that uses it as a conjunction cannot be correct. The remaining answer choices properly use "but," "so," and "although" as conjunctions, so finding the right answer becomes a matter of picking the conjunction that matches the logic of the sentence. "But" and "although" are used to indicate that the second sentence contrasts in some way with the first; this wouldn't make sense in our sentences, since they don't contrast with each other, but are related by causation: the first sentence explains the second. "So" is thus the proper conjunction to use, making the correct answer, "She was quite wary of making a scene, so she let the matter fade away with no comment."

Example Question #323 : Correcting Grammatical Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English.

After Denise showed up at her sister’s house, she realized that she had left her keys at home, she had rushed over too quickly.

Possible Answers:

she had left her keys at home therefore she had rushed over too quickly.

she had left her keys at home; she had rushed over too quickly.

she had left her keys at home, beforehand she had rushed over too quickly.

she had left her keys at home; she is rushing over too quickly.

she had left her keys at home, she had rushed over too quickly.

Correct answer:

she had left her keys at home; she had rushed over too quickly.

Explanation:

The underlined part of the sentence combines two independent clauses: "she realized that she had left her keys at home" and "she had rushed over too quickly." You can combine two independent clauses with a semicolon if they are closely related (such as if one clause causes the other, or if the second clause is explaining or clarifying the first). Only one answer choice correctly uses a semicolon without introducing other errors, and that answer choice is "she had left her keys at home; she had rushed over too quickly." The other options are incorrect because they create run-on sentences or use inconsistent verb tenses.

Example Question #172 : Comma Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English.

Many artifacts produced during the Neolithic Era were made of carved rocks, it is for this reason that the period is commonly referred to as the Stone Age.

Possible Answers:

rocks, it is for this reason that the period

rocks, which for this reason, the period

rocks, for this reason the period

rocks; and for this reason, the period

rocks; for this reason, the period

Correct answer:

rocks; for this reason, the period

Explanation:

The answer choice "rocks; for this reason, the period" contains an appropriate use of a semicolon and is correct.

The original text "rocks, it is for this reason that the period" and the answer choice "rocks, for this reason the period" each create a run-on sentence, so neither of these answers is correct.

The answer choice "rocks, which for this reason, the period" contains a misplaced relative clause and is therefore incorrect.

The answer choice "rocks; and for this reason, the period" contains an incorrect use of a semicolon. Sentences can be joined by either a comma followed by a conjunction or by a semicolon, but not by a semicolon followed by a conjunction.

 

Example Question #32 : Correcting Punctuation Errors: Comma Splices

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English.

The teacher was a stickler for order, she did not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom.

Possible Answers:

The teacher was a stickler for order; she did not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom.

The teacher was a stickler for order, she did not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom?

The teacher was a stickler for order, she did not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom.

The teacher was a stickler for order, she does not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom.

The teacher, was a stickler for order, she did not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom.

Correct answer:

The teacher was a stickler for order; she did not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom.

Explanation:

The part of the sentence that precedes the comma and the part of the sentence that comes after the comma are each independent clauses; they could stand as complete sentences by themselves. It is not grammatically correct to join two independent clauses together into a compound sentence by using just a comma; this is a grammatical error known as a "comma splice." Compound sentences may be formed using either a semicolon by itself or a comma followed by a conjunction. The only answer choice that correctly uses one of these methods to fix the sentence's comma splice is "The teacher was a stickler for order; she did not tolerate anyone acting up in her classroom."

Example Question #322 : Correcting Grammatical Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English. One of the answer choices reproduces the underlined portion as it is written in the sentence.

Television has been a controversial medium since its inception, critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s.

Possible Answers:

Television has been a controversial medium since its inception critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s.

Television has been a controversial medium since its inception; critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s.

Television has been a controversial medium since its inception so critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s.

Television has been a controversial medium since its inception and so critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s.

Television has been a controversial medium since its inception, critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s.

Correct answer:

Television has been a controversial medium since its inception; critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s.

Explanation:

The sentence is written as a compound sentence, joining two independent phrases into one sentence to show their relationship. All compound sentences, though, need to be joined either by a semicolon or a comma followed by a conjunction. The only answer choice which employs either of these options is "Television has been a controversial medium since its inception; critics were bemoaning its cultural status as early as the 1940s."

Example Question #31 : Correcting Punctuation Errors: Comma Splices

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English. One of the answer choices repeats the underlined portion as it is written.

Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble, remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity.

Possible Answers:

Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble so remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity.

Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity.

Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble and remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity.

Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble; remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity.

Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble, remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity.

Correct answer:

Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble; remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity.

Explanation:

The sentence as it is written is a compound sentence, or two complete thoughts joined together to show their relationship. All compound sentences have to be joined by either a semicolon or a comma and a conjunction. The only answer choice that does this is "Young musicians often struggle with keeping the proper tempo in an ensemble; remedying this problem is one of the things that signals a musician's growing maturity."

Example Question #323 : Correcting Grammatical Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English. One of the answer choices reproduces the underlined portion as it is written in the sentence.

In baseball, the batter must hit the ball within a ninety degree field, in cricket the batter can hit the ball anywhere.

Possible Answers:

field; but in cricket the batter can hit

field, in cricket the batter can hit

field, but in cricket the batter can hit

field; the batter in cricket hitting

field, but the batter can hit in cricket

Correct answer:

field, but in cricket the batter can hit

Explanation:

The original sentence has a comma splice. Because the two clauses contrast each other, the conjunction but is most appropriate. One choice using but is wrong because the conjunction cannot be used with a semicolon. Another choice using but is wrong because the phrase "in cricket" is misplaced.

Example Question #294 : Correcting Punctuation Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English. One of the answer choices reproduces the underlined portion as it is written in the sentence.

The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day, former supporters were switching sides with regularity.

Possible Answers:

The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day, former supporters were switching sides with regularity.

The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day so former supporters were switching sides with regularity.

The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day; former supporters were switching sides with regularity.

The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day as former supporters were switching sides with regularity.

The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day former supporters were switching sides with regularity.

Correct answer:

The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day; former supporters were switching sides with regularity.

Explanation:

The sentence written above is a compound sentence, a sentence formed by two complete thoughts that are joined to show their relationship. The appropriate ways to join complete sentences is either with a semi-colon or a comma and a conjunction. The only answer choice that does this is "The politicians grew more and more nervous about the legislation passing with each day; former supporters were switching sides with regularity."

Example Question #293 : Correcting Punctuation Errors

Replace the underlined portion with the answer choice that results in a sentence that is clear, precise, and meets the requirements of standard written English. One of the answer choices reproduces the underlined portion as it is written in the sentence.

Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles, few knew just how deep in debt he truly was.

Possible Answers:

Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles so few knew just how deep in debt he truly was.

Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles, but few knew just how deep in debt he truly was.

Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles few knew just how deep in debt he truly was.

Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles and few knew just how deep in debt he truly was.

Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles that few knew just how deep in debt he truly was.

Correct answer:

Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles, but few knew just how deep in debt he truly was.

Explanation:

The sentence is a compound sentence, two complete thoughts that are joined in one sentence. All compound sentences need to have their two parts joined by either a semicolon or a comma and a conjunction; therefore, the correct answer is "Everyone was aware of the man's financial troubles, few knew just how deep in debt he truly was."

Learning Tools by Varsity Tutors