LSAT Reading : Analogous Cases in Humanities Passages

Study concepts, example questions & explanations for LSAT Reading

varsity tutors app store varsity tutors android store

Example Questions

Example Question #21 : Analogous Cases In Humanities Passages

"The Novel" by William Floyd (2015)

The first significant period of popularity for the novel was the mid eighteenth to the early nineteenth century. Scholars have often debated why extended prose narratives became the most significant form of writing for the public during this era. Certainly the availability of cheaper publishing tools meant books were more accessible to more people, and the time period was one of widespread reading in a number of ways, such as letters and pamphlets as well as books. Yet perhaps the most significant cause of the novel’s explosion into the center of popular culture might be that it best reflected the newfound interiority and privacy of eighteenth century Western Europe.

The Industrial Revolution brought changes to nearly every element of society, but significantly transformed home life. Increased social mobility meant that multigenerational families were becoming much less common and more people lived at home. The booming wealth brought by the Industrial Revolution also created more spacious domiciles for those who were still living with family, giving most members of society a chance to have individual spaces where someone could seek out some measure of solitude. The changing social mores of the era also meant that everyday conversation began to take on a subject matter and tone that was previously seen as inappropriate or scandalous. The day to day existence and average life experience of the typical person was radically different than that of the previous generation. Whereas before the Industrial Revolution the entire social structure of the world revolved around community, by the mid seventeenth century the individual became the center of the social universe.

All of these changes perfectly suited the strengths of the novel, particularly as it was written and consumed in the eighteenth century. Where a play has at its core a public performance and poetry was meant to be said aloud, the novel provides a focus on interior thoughts, psychology, and character development. For a world newly experiencing privacy and intimate space, the conversational style and philosophical musings of the novel matched the new reality that the novel reader was encountering. More significantly, the most popular novels, until about the twentieth century, were usually published in a serialized format. By getting the next installment each week or month, readers consumed novels in much the same manner as they read letters from home or snippets of news. Novels fit into the fabric of life during the Industrial Revolution because they were about interiority, individualism, and striving for something new.

Which of the following connections is most similar to the relationship proposed by the author between the Industrial Revolution and the popularity of novels?

Possible Answers:

Plays were first produced on a wide scale after architecture allowed for large theaters to have adequate acoustics.

Popular entertainments of the nineteenth century were often nostalgic diversions that recalled a more rural way of life.

Talking movies became immensely popular because they reflected the fast-moving, modern sensibility of mid-century audiences.

Popular music genres are usually far inferior to classical music in musicianship, theory, and composition.

Poetry has always been the most significant form of literature in times of prosperity.

Correct answer:

Talking movies became immensely popular because they reflected the fast-moving, modern sensibility of mid-century audiences.

Explanation:

While the author's argument is that the conditions of the Industrial Revolution helped spur the novel's popularity, it is significant that the argument has very little to do with technological changes but instead views the success of novels as a reflection of a changing culture. The only answer choice which makes a claim about a popular art form relating to cultural norms in a particular way is "Talking movies became immensely popular because they reflected the fast-moving, modern sensibility of mid-century audiences."

Example Question #22 : Analogous Cases In Humanities Passages

"Perspective" by William Floyd (2015)

In the visual arts, “perspective” describes creating a two-dimensional image which has the illusion of depth and shading to make it appear like a three-dimensional image. The ability to paint with perspective was a Renaissance idea, when painters such as Jan van Eyck and Leonardo da Vinci created scenes which had a revolutionary look, particularly as compared to the notably flat medieval paintings of earlier artists. These reflected life in a way that it was thought painting could never hope to achieve. The question that obviously arises from this revolution in painting is why the artists of the middle ages felt so comfortable with their lack of such perspective.

The fifteenth century Italian painter and Dominican friar born Guido Pietri was dubbed Fra Beato Angleico, which in English is “the Blessed Angelic Friar,” for the way he captured the imagination of his contemporaries. While he painted less than a century before da Vinci, Fra Angelico appears to belong to a different tradition entirely, with a completely different aesthetic sense. His portraits are oddly formal, while his crowd scenes are so busy as to be overwhelming. To look at his “Annunciation of the Virgin” or “Last Judgement” is to see a painting which is almost too flat and busy, necessitating a careful look at each element, moving across the painting, rather than being able to take in the entire scene of the painting at once.

Which might be the actual expectation of a medieval painter. Any scene with a dozen saints has such precision in the portrayal of each saint, who has to be recognizable to every worshipful person viewing it, that it requires an up close view of every single element. Additionally, the subject matter is presented in such a way as to make the viewer move from left to right. This essentially means that a medieval viewer “read” a painting as much as they viewed it. Each element was a self-contained piece which needed to be viewed in a specific order. Rather than conveying one scene, the painting was actually more of a storytelling device. Naturally, the time of perspective was also the time the printing press brought widespread literacy to Europe. With more people being able to read a text, a painting had less need to function as a text itself, making a revolution in painting a necessity for the genre.

Which of the following is an analagous case to that presented in the passage?

Possible Answers:

Color photography's dominance in photojournalism made black and white photography largely a pursuit of the fine arts.

The use of better microphones made recorded sound prefer intimate performances over louder instruments and voices.

Talking pictures showed how inadequate silent films were in telling complex stories.

The rise of professional athletics severely weakened the talent pool for amateur athletic competitions.

Modern dance's focus on movement rather than storytelling diminished the general public's taste for dance.

Correct answer:

The use of better microphones made recorded sound prefer intimate performances over louder instruments and voices.

Explanation:

The passage describes the way in which the use of perspective changed the way people viewed large paintings. Similarly, a change in the technology of recording music made the approach to creating music drastically different before and after the new approach was introduced, valuing different techniques and strategies.

Example Question #23 : Analogous Cases In Humanities Passages

"Ed Sullivan and All the Rest" by William Floyd (2015)

Modern television talk shows center on the host, with the guests as a side dish that still accentuates the main entrée of the funny person at the center of the spectacle. Their forerunners were on television as early as television was in American homes, scene stealers such as Steve Allen and Jack Parr making even the most famous celebrities play inside their world. At the same time, though, one man showed how a television show could highlight a variety of performers, from the remarkable to the mundane and the famous to the unknown. If more television shows operated like “The Ed Sullivan Show,” maybe television would be less ego centric.

Ed Sullivan began his career before World War II as an entertainment and sports reporter, gaining his first significant notoriety as a celebrity maker for his gossip column in the New York Daily News. This influential position led him to be chosen as the host of “The Toast of the Town,” a variety show on CBS, in 1948. He was awkward on camera and made no effort to be a schmoozer or comedian. Despite his awkwardness, Ed Sullivan became a household name, with his show first informally and then officially being known as “The Ed Sullivan Show.” No one cared about watching Sullivan himself, but rather what Sullivan presented to his audience each week. Sullivan was a force behind the scenes, putting together the show that everyone wanted to watch each week.

The genius of Sullivan’s show was that it was truly a variety show. Sullivan made sure to show his audience ballet and opera selections, yet also never shied away from presenting Rock n Roll acts on his prestigious time slot. He was also a key benefactor for a number of young comedians, who would present their usual stand-up routines free of comment in front of a national audience. Naturally, the Beatles were not actually big in America until they had gotten the Sullivan anointment, but many other acts could credit Sullivan with a breakthrough. Considering the time he was on the air, 1948 to 1971, Sullivan made twentieth century American popular culture. With the fragmentation of culture through cable, the internet, and streaming services, no one can ever hope to have the same impact as a man described as having the personality of an Easter Island statue.

Which of the following statements would be an analogous case to that presented in the passage?

Possible Answers:

Modern television talk show hosts need to watch more kinds of television than just other talk shows.

Modern newspaper columnists are not as popular as those of the past, and should the modern writers emulate earlier columnists.

Gossip columnists should be given more responsibility in places outside of newspapers.

Internet celebrities should attempt to act more like television talk show hosts.

Radio hosts need to be more charismatic and funny than television hosts due to the differences in the two forms of media.

Correct answer:

Modern newspaper columnists are not as popular as those of the past, and should the modern writers emulate earlier columnists.

Explanation:

The passage presents the case that modern television show hosts should act more like Ed Sullivan because he was more popular and influential in his own time. A similar case is that newspaper columnists should seek to be more popular by writing more like columnists who were extremely popular in the past.

Example Question #412 : Lsat Reading Comprehension

Passage adapted from Shakespearean Playhouses (1917) by Joseph Quincy Adams.

Before the building of regular playhouses, the itinerant troupes of actors were accustomed, except when received into private homes, to give their performances in any place that chance provided, such as open street-squares, barns, town-halls, moot-courts, schoolhouses, churches, and—most frequently of all, perhaps—the yards of inns. These yards, especially those of carriers' inns, were admirably suited to dramatic representations, consisting as they did of a large open court surrounded by two or more galleries. Many examples of such inn-yards are still to be seen in various parts of England... In the yard a temporary platform—a few boards, it may be, set on barrel-heads—could be erected for a stage; in the adjacent stables a dressing-room could be provided for the actors; the rabble—always the larger and more enthusiastic part of the audience—could be accommodated with standing-room about the stage; while the more aristocratic members of the audience could be comfortably seated in the galleries overhead. Thus a ready-made and very serviceable theatre was always at the command of the players; and it seems to have been frequently made use of from the very beginning of professionalism in acting.

One of the earliest extant moralities, Mankind, acted by strollers in the latter half of the fifteenth century, gives us an interesting glimpse of an inn-yard performance. The opening speech makes distinct reference to the two classes of the audience described above as occupying the galleries and the yard:

"O ye sovereigns that sit, and ye brothers that stand right up."

The "brothers," indeed, seem to have stood up so closely about the stage that the actors had great difficulty in passing to and from their dressing-room. Thus, Nowadays leaves the stage with the request:

“Make space, sirs, let me go out!”

New Gyse enters with the threat:

“Out of my way, sirs, for dread of a beating!”

While Nought, with even less respect, shouts:

“Avaunt, knaves! Let me go by!”

Language such as this would hardly be appropriate if addressed to the "sovereigns" who sat in the galleries above; but, as addressed to the "brothers," it probably served to create a general feeling of good nature. And a feeling of good nature was desirable, for the actors were facing the difficult problem of inducing the audience to pay for its entertainment.

Which of the following examples presents an analogous case to that made in the passage?

Possible Answers:

Athletes are most beholden to their fans in the way they perform athletic feats.

Politicians often find their positions through asking specific questions of their supporters.

An author's readership can be understood from the way they are described in the author's writing.

A painter's influence is most notable in subsequent artists who used a similar aesthetic.

A poet's cultural background is most visible in the specific metaphors employed in the poetry.

Correct answer:

An author's readership can be understood from the way they are described in the author's writing.

Explanation:

The author directly claims that the nature of performance in fifteenth century theater is easily deducible from the way that the actors directly addressed their audience. An analagous case would be that an author's readership is most clearly seen in the way the author addresses it, as that also is a case reliant on using textual information to extrapolate about other information.

Tired of practice problems?

Try live online LSAT prep today.

1-on-1 Tutoring
Live Online Class
1-on-1 + Class
Learning Tools by Varsity Tutors